How to built an email marketing database
If there’s one thing I hang my hat on, it’s email marketing. It’s the cornerstone of a well-rounded inbound marketing strategy. I grew a subscriber list from 0 to 40,000 leads organically during the first year I launched BARTable. That’s because email is one the most effective marketing channels to drive website traffic, leads and sales (yes, beating out social media, SEO and content marketing).
Why? Because most people have email, and more than half of cell phone users access their email on the phone. The average person checks their email 15 times a day (guilty). And if there’s a subject line stating I can get 40% off my next clothing purchase, I’m guaranteed to open it and will probably look around. And it’s not just me — 86% of people would like to receive promo emails from companies they like.
Personally, I love how versatile email marketing is — it’s customization, easy to integrate with your other marketing tactics and cheap. But let’s be real — a lot of those emails feel spammy, and we’re inundated with them. The average office worker receives 121 emails per day. That’s a lot of noise to cut through.
Today, I want to walk you through how to build an email marketing database and tips for sending your very first campaign.
Step 1: Build a quality email database
Repeat after me: “I will not buy or rent an email list.”
I’ve encountered more than a few people who’ve bragged about their large subscriber list (“I have more than 100,000 email contacts!”), but when I quizzed them about open rates, click rates and sales, those numbers are dismal. Why? Because they purchased an email list based on a desired demographic (e.g., single people who live in San Francisco) and spammed them with content they did not solicit.
What are the chances you will open an email from an unfamiliar brand or business? None. And if you do, it’s to immediately unsubscribe and block the sender.
It may be tempting to buy an email list, but there are other reasons why it’s frowned upon:
You’ll violate the General Data Protection Regulation, a European data privacy act that states you must have explicit consent to send your contacts emails.
Email marketing software doesn’t allow you to send to lists that you purchased. I mostly use MailChimp to send marketing campaigns, and they insist on opt-ins to build your email list.
You’ll harm your reputation score. Did you know that there are systems that track spam complaints, hard bounces and other metrics that can impact your “reputation”? Yup. I had a colleague who asked me to send a campaign to an email list she created. When I sent it, my reputation score got a ding because it hard bounced to more than 25% of the subscribers on the list. Why? Because the email addresses were gleaned from a survey from 5 years ago.
It’s annoying! Nuff said.
So how DO you build a marketing database? Here are some proven ideas …
Create an opt-in box on your website. You may find those pop-ups annoying, but they’re effective.
Leverage your social media. Use your social media accounts to ask people to sign-up. You’ll see greater success if you add an incentive (e.g., 10% your first purchase, or a free consultation). This brings me to the next point …
Use prizes or discounts as an incentive. For BART, I grew the marketing database by asking venues to donate prizes. I would create a viral sweepstakes requiring them to sign up for the newsletter (e.g., sign up to win a pair of tickets to see “Hamilton”), and then segment them in the database by interests. A word of warning for this technique: You don’t want your subscribers just to come for the freebies. Be sure to include valuable content as well (more on that in Step 2).
Physical sign-up: If you have a brick-and-mortar business, host a booth at a festival or conduct outreach events, ask them to sign up to stay in the loop.
Add subscribe link in your email signature. This takes little effort, and you can get quality leads from people you interact with online.
Step 2: Send great content
After you pulled together your database, you have an email to write.
Like I mentioned before, I like MailChimp for its ease of use, knowledge base and third-party integration. It’s free to use if you have less than 2,000 subscribers. You can also go beyond email to create ads, landing pages and sign-up forms.
Once you have secured an email marketing tool to send your messages, it’s time to put together a compelling email.
Go beyond your subscriber’s expectations and send them information that is relevant to them. If you are a business, your customers expect to receive emails that contain a sales pitch, order confirmation or tracking code. But if you also add relevant and valuable information, you more likely to keep people engaged. For example, if you are a company that sells mattresses, include a link to a blog post about how to properly take care of it. If you are a health coach, send a PDF with a 7-day nutrition guide.
People will engage with content that is:
Relevant: Send information that the subscriber wants to read. You can really hone in on this through segmentation.
Timely: I received a “Happy New Year” email in February. It felt stale and I couldn’t understand why I was receiving it.
Consistent: Decide on how often you want to send content. Weekly? Monthly? Whatever you decide on, be consistent about it.
Personalized: The inbox is used for personal conversation, and your email is going to be competing with a lot of other noise.
Well written: Your email needs to be easy to read and grammatically correct. Sending an email with a lot of typos will make you lose credibility. Hire a professional if you need help.
Aesthetically pleasing: You only have a few seconds to grab a reader’s attention. If your email is filled with images that are not sized properly, it’s laid out in a way that’s confusing to read or doesn’t look professional, it’ll land in the trash.
Not so sales-y: People can tell when they are being pitched. Be human in your emails. Care about the person you are selling to, and understand their needs and challenges. Your email has to add value to your subscriber’s life, and if it’s a generic message of “buy my product,” they’ll tune out.
Step 3: Segment, segment, segment
As a savvy marketer, you know the importance of creating an avatar. And if you just read the previous sentence and have no idea what I’m talking about, that’s OK too. (An avatar, aka buyer persona, is a fictional character that represents distinct consumers of your product).
When writing an email, you shouldn’t think that it’s for everybody. You should have a specific target (or avatar) in mind. This is where segmentation comes to play. If you are able to segment your subscribed audience by their interests, communication preferences, demographics, etc., you can deliver an email that’s relevant to them. The more personalized the email is, the more likely someone will open it and make a purchase.
You can begin segmenting your list at the moment they subscribe to it. Ask questions like: How often do you want to hear from us? What are you interested in knowing? What kinds of emails do you want to receive?
With this information, you can start personalizing emails to your subscriber list. You can further survey your segments down the road to find out more about them. Factor in purchase history, engagement rates and downloads to add further relevancy to your emails.
Step 4: Analytics
Now that your email database is up and running, you’re ready to dive a little deeper and take a look at the analytics. Check your dashboard to see your open rate, click through rate and unsubscribes. Each of these are very important when you send future campaigns.
Your open rate tells how many people opened the email you sent. To me, it’s a clue to how effective your subject line and how credible your relationship is to your subscriber. A low open rate means your subscribers are not engaged. This would be a time to evaluate the content you are sending (go through the checklist in Step 2) and to tweak your emails accordingly.
Your click through rate tells how many people clicked on a link inside of your email. This is a clue to how engaging your copy is and if it is compelling enough for your subscriber to take action.
The unsubscribe rate tells you how many people opted out of your email list. If you’re losing more people than you’re adding to your database, you should re-evaluate your email marketing strategy. Take a look at when people are unsubscribing to your list and take action accordingly. If you notice that people are unsubscribing after they received a sales-y email, you want to retool how you pitch your product.
Bottom Line
With its huge ROI and relevancy, you can’t ignore email marketing. Once you mastered these basics, you move on to creating automated emails, A/B test, dig deeper into analytics and continue to segment.
How do you use email marketing for your client or business?